A Game of One’s Own: Towards a New Gendered Poetics of Digital Space
Tracy
Fullerton,
USC
School of Cinematic Arts, Los Angeles
Jacquelyn
Ford Morie,
USC
Institute for Creative Technologies
Celia
Pearce,
Georgia
Institute of Technology, Atlanta
Introduction
Je suis l’espace où je suis
I am the space where I am.
-Noël Arnaud, L’Etat d’ebauche
In the opening pages of her classic essay, A Room of Ones
Own, Virginia Woolf describes being blocked from entering the “turf” of the
University in Oxbridge by an administrative gate-keeper.
Instantly a
man’s figure rose to intercept me. ... His face expressed horror and indignation.
Instinct rather than reason came to my help, he was a Beadle; I was a woman.
This was the turf; there was the path. Only the Fellows and Scholars are
allowed here; the gravel is the place for me’ (Woolf, 1929).
This scene invokes
the ways in which women have been systematically barred from the digital
playground, both as players and as creators of play space. To a large extent,
the video game industry in the U.S. remains dominated by a boys-only ethos that
harkens back to the gender-biased practices in the British academia of Woolf’s
day. [1] Games that are female-friendly are often couched in derogatory or
dismissive terms: The Sims (Maxis, 2000) is ‘not really a game’; casual
games are not counted as ‘real’ games by many in the industry.[2] The result
is that certain types of games, game mechanics, play patterns, and, as we’ll
see, particular types of game spaces have tended to dominate the field of
games.
Although this
paper discusses the ways in which digital game spaces have been strongly gendered
towards male constructions of space and play, this does not necessarily mean we
advocate creating exclusively female (or ‘pink’) games. As Woolf points out in
her essay, the solution is not simply to create a distinctly feminine voice
(although this is one potential angle of approach), but rather to promote the
cultivation of an ‘androgynous mind’, which, she suggests, is already possessed
by male authors of great note throughout history (she cites Shakespeare as an
example). We propose drawing from a number of cultural practices, literary
sources, and existing games in order to pave the way for a playground that is
more open to female players. Thus we promote not only the definition of new
feminine game spaces, but also encourage designers to think in terms of ‘androgynous
space’ that engages all aspects of all persons: a space into which women and
girls are invited and welcomed, but in which men and boys can also enjoy more
diverse and nuanced forms of play than are typically available to them.
The Production of Space
Gendering Game Space
The concept
of space itself is not a simple one, and it is not possible to do it justice
here. Space may be described by its physical dimensions, or by its
mathematical, material, or geographic properties. It may also be understood as
a social practice or psychological phenomenon, as in the work of Situationist
Henri Lefebrvre (1991). The ways in which humans understand and represent
space are social constructions that serves as a barometer of a particular culture
and time. At different points in history, and within different contexts, space
and its representations have proceeded from varying cultural ideals — from the 15th century paintings in which size of objects was used to denote importance, not
relative position in a landscape, to the secret mathematics of vision that
instructed the creation of perspective in Renaissance art and architecture.
When Europeans arrived in the Americas, one of the rationales for colonialism
was that the natives were ‘not using’ the land. Other representations of
navigable space include cartographic traditions such as Mercator projections,
which distorted the relative size of the continents in order to fit the entire
globe on a cylinder, and modern GPS coordinate systems. In 1946, Buckminster
Fuller created the ‘dymaxion map’, or ‘Fuller Projection’, an icosahedral globe
that represented the continents at true scale. Representations of space often
reveal the priorities and perceptions of the prevailing culture at the time.
Both Pearce (1997) and Konzack (2006) have noted a spatial transition in video
games. In contrast with earlier more abstract forms of expression in digital
games, there is tendency within the game industry today to focus on the
production of ‘realistic’ representations of space — detailed, three-dimensional
models of what Lefebvre would call ‘lived space’, or what Soja terms ‘Firstspace’
(1996). But whose lived space? Game space, due in part to the constraints of
the computer, and in part to the way in which 3D technologies have been
developed, is overwhelmingly Western, Cartesian and male.
The success
of 3D computer modeling within the film industry as a means of bringing fantasy
to life seems to have also resulted in a fixation on ‘realistic’ representation
within the game industry. However it must be acknowledged that this fixation
on realism — especially in the representation of game space — is somewhat different
than the concept of actual lived space. Espen Aarseth, echoing Janet Murray’s
previous work, has claimed, ‘the defining element in computer games is
spatiality’, however, he says it is ‘the difference between the spatial
representation and real space’ that makes gameplay rules possible. In
describing a topology of game spaces, ranging from textual, two-dimensional,
isometric, three-dimensional, etc., he concludes that in their careful planning
as playable game spaces, they are in fact, not realistic at all, but
allegorical, ‘figurative comments on the impossibility of representing real
space’ (Aarseth, 1998).
Aarseth’s
description of how game spaces ignore real-world constraints, using teleporters
and distributing resources across the terrain to make gameplay fair, is not as
interesting as his unintentional focus on what is done in game
landscapes themselves, i.e. the ‘unreality’ of these landscapes is not only due
to their order and balance, but also to their inherent usefulness for a certain
type of gameplay — generally battle. As Aarseth (1998) says, ‘Every game of Myth (Bungie Studios, 1997) is a fight for position in the landscape … the units
will go and do as ordered (with a simple click on the unit and then a click on
the position or enemy to be taken) but when the chaos of battle erupts,
efficient control is no longer possible, and much therefore depends on how well
the player has taken advantage of formation, landscape variation and knowledge
of enemy positions’.
Dangerous and Contested Spaces
Aarseth’s
description of a landscape designed for battle is typical of many digital game
spaces, and speaks to a predominantly male concern that space is potentially
dangerous and always contested. In order to better understand the specifics of
this gendering of game space, it is useful to analyze in more detail the
prevailing characteristics of these environments. Looking back to the abstract
battlefields of games like chess or Go, or to today’s real-time strategy (RTS)
or ‘God Games’ like the Age of Empires (Ensemble Studios, 1997) and Civilization series (Micropose Software, 1992), it is clear these games define space
primarily by its ability to be captured or held by players. Core mechanics
revolve around intellectual problem-solving and resource management with the
main objective being to amass armies, expand territories, control resources,
and dominate the play space of the game.
Turn-of-the-Century
feminist Charlotte Perkins Gilman characterizes the contrast between male and
female relations to space:
The basic feminine impulse is to
gather, to put together, to construct; the basic masculine impulse is to
scatter, to disseminate, to destroy. It seems to give pleasure to a man
to bang something and drive it from him; the harder he hits it and the farther
it goes the better pleased he is (Gilman, 1911).
She also
points out the ‘universal dominance of the projectile’ in male sport,
epitomized in digital games by the contested space of the first-person shooter
(FPS) genre. The core game mechanic of a typical first-person shooter can be
seen as a cross between a carnival shooting gallery with moving targets, cops
and robbers, and in the case of team-based games such as Counter-Strike (Le
and Cliff, 1999) or Halo 2 (Bungie Studios, 2004), what might be
described as ‘tag on steroids’. These games conceive of moving through space
in a distinctly masculine fashion, in terms of both its role in the game
experience, and the narrative milieu in which they take place. They epitomize
what Judith Butler would call ‘disciplinary regimes’ that through repetitive
performance construct both gender and gendered space (Butler, 1990). Their game
mechanics value particular skills: mastery of quick reflexes and an ability to
solve complex spatial rotation problems in real time. These are the hallmarks
of the FPS, skills which cognitive research suggests, by and large, tend to
favor males (Terlecki and Newcombe, 2005).
In contrast
to the narrative maze described by Murray, in which a story unfolds through a
process of spatial navigation (Murray, 1997), the FPS maze is envisioned as an
obstacle course around and through which tactical maneuvers take place. The ‘story’
is often incidental to the game mechanic, providing merely a motivation,
back-story and mis-en-scene for what is otherwise a fairly generic
activity. In these games hiding places, vistas, avenues of escape and
dead-ends combine with strategic decisions about weaponry to create a
particular type of tactical pleasure. While these pleasures can appeal to both
males and females, it is clear that they are geared to the former audience
(apropos Gillman). And, when the theme or story overlay is added, we see an
even stronger orientation to male domains.
Thematically,
these games revolve around narratives of warfare, anti-terrorism, invading
aliens, zombies, science fiction, combat with robots, etc. Aesthetically,
their settings tend to be highly rectilinear, typically manmade spaces, often
the bruised and embattled remains of an urban environment, warehouse, office
building, space ship, space colony, or high tech laboratory gone horribly
wrong. They are typically constructed of hard materials: cinder block, metal
grid work, HVAC infrastructure, with heavily mechanical components, reinforced
by the sound effects of footsteps echoing on metal or concrete floors. They are
often bleak, militaristic, post apocalyptic or futuristic. Spaces are dimly lit
and color palettes are dark and monochromatic. Consider the sharp contrast
between the color palette of Half-Life (Valve Software, 1998) or Doom (id Software, 1993) and that of a game such as Animal Crossing (Nintendo
EAD, 2002). In the former, exterior scenes are rare, and if included, tend to
take place in battlefields, deserts, decimated landscapes or contested areas of
urban blight. If, as Duchenaut et al (2004) suggest, games provide the digital
equivalent of a ‘Third Place’ outside of home and work (Oldenburg, 1989) what
kinds of ‘Third Places’ are we creating with these landscape of destruction?
As Bachelard states, in The Poetics of Space:
It is also a terrible trait of men that they should be
incapable of understanding the forces of the universe intuitively, otherwise
that in terms of psychology of wrath (Bachelard, 1964, 1958).
It is
interesting to contrast these scenarios with Gilman’s Utopian vision of Herland,
a novel in which women form the dominate culture in a society free of war,
poverty and even garbage (Gilman, 1979, 1915).
Levels and Secrets
Another
common trait of male-gendered game spaces is their organizational structures.
The majority of digital games are presented in a series of ‘levels’ which escalate
in difficulty, barring those who cannot master the skills and secrets of the
game are barred from advancing. Like a skyscraper, the indomitable symbol of
the business hierarchy, or the strict chain of command in the military, games
are positioned to ‘keep out’ those who have not passed the tests of earlier
levels. Progression and advancement are possible only through ‘beating’ these
levels, ‘conquering’ their secrets in a highly linear fashion. And secrets
themselves are framed as tasks or challenges, which often hold access to even
more exclusive spaces. Only by knowing exactly where the entrance to a secret
level is, can the players prove themselves worthy of entering. What is found
inside these secret spaces are rewards that are sometimes humorous, sometimes
offensive, and sometimes reinforce an insider’s knowledge of the game.
Examples of these secret levels and places can be found in the early Atari game Adventure (Robinett, 1980), with its infamous Easter egg room displaying
programmer Warren Robinett’s forbidden credit, to a secret ‘glitch’ that became
known as ‘Minus World’ in Super Mario Bros (Nintendo, 1985), insider
joke levels such as level 31 in Doom II, which borrowed enemies from id
Software’s earlier game Wolfenstein 3D (Muse Software, 1981), or the
infamous secret ‘Hot Coffee’ scene in Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas,
which, when unlocked, enabled a sex ‘minigame’ between the main character and
his girlfriend.
Knowing how
and where to access these secrets is the province of ‘real gamers’ and while
these male fantasies of progressing through power acquisition, tactical
mastery, secret knowledge or geographic domination can and are certainly
enjoyable for women to play, they are not necessarily ‘indigenous’ to the ways
in which women and girls experience space, especially in the context of play.
Just as Virginia Woolf argued that women need an indigenous voice of their own,
women also need the opportunity to explore and manifest their own indigenous
fantasy play space.
Girls in Boyland
Historically,
in the non-digital playground, girls have been spatially constrained in their
play activities. The ‘roaming radius’ study done in the U.S. in 1960s by John
Newson and Elizabeth Newson (1968) demonstrated that in the playground, boys
are typically allowed to roam further than girls. Follow-up studies in the
1970s found that a typical ten- to twelve-year old boy was allowed to travel a
distance of 2,452 yards, while girls of the same age might only travel 959
yards (Margolis and Fisher, 2001). It was not until 1972 with Title IX,
over 50 years after women’s suffrage, that girls were allowed equal access to
the sports field in schools. Encoded in these constraints are implicit
stereotyped anxieties about the vulnerabilities of girls: on the one hand, they
are weaker and more fragile than boys; on the other, they may fall prey to
sexual predators.
Reactions to
such constraints often call for inclusiveness — girls must be ‘allowed’ to play
in boys’ spaces, by boys’ rules, in order to master them and increase their
ability to compete more efficiently in a male-dominated world. In From
Barbie to Mortal Kombat, Henry Jenkins proposes:
We need to open up more space for
girls to join–or play alongside–the traditional boy culture down by the river,
in the old vacant lot, within the bamboo forest. Girls need to learn how to
explore 'unsafe' and 'unfriendly' spaces, and to experience the 'complete
freedom of movement' promised by the boys’ games, if not all the time, then at
least some of the time, to help them develop the self-confidence and
competitiveness demanded of professional women. They also need to learn how, in
the words of a contemporary bestseller, to 'run with the wolves' and not just
follow the butterflies. Girls need to be able to play games where Barbie gets
to kick some butt (Jenkins, 1998).
There are
many facets to the notion of ‘Barbie kicking butt’. On the surface, the
concept could be epitomized by Lara Croft, the busty adventuress who takes on
male game space in hot pants, a tight tank top and a holster. Early on, Lara’s
creators insisted that centering on a strong female character in Tomb Raider (Core Design, 1996) would translate into strong appeal to women and girls. But
this noble intention did not materialize: Lara Croft, like many other female
game characters, is a male fantasy of Barbie kicking butt. Similarly, in games
like Virtua Fighter (SEGA-AM2 Co, 1995) and Tekken (Namco, 1995),
sexy female characters don what author Pearce has dubbed ‘kombat lingerie’ to
engage in what might otherwise be considered traditionally male activities. In
the end, these may be merely examples of what Simone de Beauvoir (1952) would
characterize as the woman as ‘other’ inhabiting a ‘masculine universe’ in a
male-defined role.
Whether or not
these environments are empowering to women is debatable: putting a female
character into a male game space, particularly one that caters more to male
fantasies of female empowerment than those of actual females, seems only to
make matters worse. Indeed, these female objects of male fantasy not only fail
to resonate with many women players, but alienate them still further. As T.L.
Taylor’s research shows, many women play the over-sexualized, underdressed
avatars in Massively Multiplayer Online Games (MMOGs) in spite of their
design, and would prefer to have a less excessively endowed character if
given the choice (Taylor, 2003). In the long run, Lara and her butt-kicking
buddies have failed where Barbie has succeeded. Perhaps its appeal (or lack
thereof) lies not in the representation of character but the gendered nature of
the space itself. Perhaps butt-kicking is not what many girls and women have
in mind as a form of empowerment through play. [3]
Feminine Conceptions of Space
Literary Models for Regendering Game Space
Following
Woolf’s lead, we have identified some literary and game traditions that offer
rich conceptions of space from a female perspective. In these spaces, female
characters figure predominately, if not solely, and the ways in which they
interact with the space, as well as the character of the spaces themselves, can
be looked at as models for a more feminine conception of space. Indeed, many
late 19th and early 20th Century male authors had a
better grasp of feminine space than today’s game designers. Classic children’s
literature, such as Alice in Wonderland (Carroll, 1865), The Wizard
of Oz (Baum, 1900), The Chronicles of Narnia (Lewis, 1950), The
Secret Garden (Burnett, 1909), and Mary Poppins (Travers, 1934),
among others, offer a cast of female heroines who open portals to and explore
magical, alternative, sometimes highly treacherous mythical and imaginary
worlds that often provide an allegory for inner-space. These women are brave,
curious, adventuresome, and smart, solving complex problems to arrive at their
destinations, which invariably turn out to be some inner state of
transformation.
Again we can
invoke Bachelard (1964), who speaks of
…[attributing] grace to curves, and, no doubt, inflexibility
to straight lines? Why is it worse for us to say that an angle is cold and a
curve warm? That the curve welcomes us and the oversharp angle rejects us?
That the angle is masculine and the curve feminine? A modicum of quality
changes everything. The grace of a curve is an invitation to remain.
Secret Places
Secrecy is,
like the game spaces described above, a large part of classic children’s
literature, and specifically literature focusing on female characters. Frances
Hodgson Burnett’s The Secret Garden, for instance, has been a perennial
tome of girlhood for decades and tells of how orphan Mary Lennox and her
invalid cousin, Colin, find a long-neglected secret garden, a place to grow and
heal, both physically and psychologically, through cultivating a natural
environment. In the musical stage performance based on the book, Mary echoes
Woolf’s insistence that to write a woman must have a room of her own:
I need a place where I can hide,
Where no one sees my life inside,
Where I can make my plans, and write them down
So I can read them.
A place where I can bid my heart be still
And it will mind me.
A place where I can go when I am lost,
And there I'll find me
(Norman and Simon, 1993)
The affinity
with nature, a common theme, is central to Purple Moon’s Secret Paths series (Purple Moon Software, 1996-1998), in which girls explored various
landscapes and then met in a secret tree house to share stories. Like the
psychologically safe space offered by Burnett’s Secret Garden, the
secret tree house of the Purple Moon game was framed not in terms of mastery
and exclusivity, like the hidden game levels described above, but rather in
terms of growth, bonding, intimacy, privacy and narratives. This female-framed
secrecy presents a very different set of play mechanics and design possibilities.
In Remembrance and the Design of Place, architecture professor Frances
Downing says of secret spaces:
A secret place always has aspects of a ‘removed’ existence,
being a place that, physically or mentally, it is created for retreat,
intimacy, enclosure, screening, and protection. These often are places of
power and control that cannot be known or invaded by ‘outside’ forces (Downing,
2000).
In
enumerating the many domains of the experience of space from accounts of male
and female architects, Downing points out the notion of the unfinished places
that invite contribution from the inhabitant: secret, ancestral, places of
self, sensate places, places of desire, comfort, region, vicarious, gregarious
and abstract. Of secret spaces she says: ‘Built forms of this domain often
were places that were unfinished — attics, root cellars, or under the
stairs. Often their unfinished nature provided a sense of ownership
through an ability to complete the place with one’s presence. Closets and
large furniture also were important in this category’. These alternative
universes cry out for player agency, for players to not only be transformed by,
but also to transform the space as part of the play experience and, as we will
see, they are also often the transitional point into another type of
imaginative space, which we will discuss next.
Enchanted
Worlds
Even before
J.R.R. Tolkien presented the definitive fantasy world that set the stage for
numerous digital games, girls in literature had the power to open portals into
alternative universes. The late 19th and early 20th Centuries hosted a parade of what would now be called ‘tween’ girls venturing
forth into the uncharted territory of inner space: Alice ventured down the
rabbit hole and into the inner space of the looking glass; Dorothy rode a gust
of wind to a magical land; Lucy lead the way into a vast alternative,
allegorical universe.
Dorothy and
Alice provide an interesting juxtaposition of girls in gamespace. They are
similar in many ways, and yet their motivations and passages are quite
different. Dorothy, longing for adventure and escape from the mundane of the
domestic, is swept away against her will on a gust of wind. She commits a
seemingly heroic act by accident, by landing inadvertently on the Wicked Witch
of the East. Her nurturing and generous personality makes her the unwitting
leader of a motley crew of displaced ‘persons’ (not necessarily people). The ‘yellow
brick road’ becomes Dorothy’s avenue, quite literally, for adventure. In the
words of George Sand: ‘What is more beautiful than a road?’ (Sand, 1845). Yet
adventure notwithstanding, the outcome of Dorothy’s travails is the realization
that, indeed, the domestic space has all she needs.
Alice,
suffering equally from tween girl ennui, is much more pro-active about her
adventures. Rather than merely wishing herself into an enchanted world,
she actively seeks it out. The following passage from the delightful 1923
digest of children’s literature, Boys and Girls of Bookland, provides
insight not only into Alice’s universal appeal, but also into her modus
operandi:
Alice, you must know, was an
adventurous young person, much more so than the heroines of the ordinary fairy
tales, for when they wandered away from home it was generally because they were
forced to do so, while Alice deliberately made up her mind to travel, and Did
It! (sic) (Smith, 1923).
Alice’s
adventures take her through a variety of transformations in scale, another
aspect of space; she grows and shrinks (an allegory for growing up) and even
swims through a pool of her own tears. It is also worth noting that Alice was a
‘gamer’ of sorts: both of her excursions took her into worlds that revolved
around a central game: cards, in Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland (Carroll,
1865), and chess in Through the Looking Glass (Carroll, 1871). Thus
Alice’s imaginary worlds are also very explicitly ‘game worlds’ in a way that
perhaps the others mentioned here are not. [4]
Note that
three of these four adventures originate via portals to parallel universes that
are situated in domestic space. As Bachelard points out: ‘the house shelters
daydreaming, the house protects the dreamer, the house allows one to dream in
peace’ (1964, 1958). Thus the domestic becomes a portal into imaginary worlds.
Furthermore, he points out the evocative nature of drawers, chests and
wardrobes — secret enclosures that are meant to be opened, and which recur
throughout the literature of this genre. The wardrobe, the mirror are portals
into the imagination for the inquisitive girl adventurer. ‘For to great
dreamers of corners and holes, nothing is ever empty’ (Bachelard, 1964).
Although
domestic space can be a site of play and pleasure, (as described in the
following section), it can also connote stifling captivity for women, as in
Perkins Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper (Gilman, 1997, 1892), in
which a woman is confined in a deteriorating room by a loving yet
paternalistically controlling husband. She is also discouraged from writing,
because it exacerbates her ‘hysteria’, thus the room also represents the
repression of her inner life, and consequential descent into madness.
Conversely, for Woolf, A Room of One’s Own (and of one’s own making)
also means the space (and time) in which to daydream; it is ‘room to
move’, room to amble, wander and let the imagination run wild (Woolf, 1929).
Alice’s adventures are literally explained away as dreams. In Narnia,
Lucy leads a group of adventurous children into a world of spiritual allegory
through a wardrobe, one of the domestic realm’s secret containers that are ‘meant
to be opened’ (Bachelard, 1964, 1958). Both Dorothy and Alice inhabit dream
worlds to which their imaginations give rise. Lucy and the children of Narnia also inhabit a dream world, but one which is deeply serious and allegorical.
None of these make-believe worlds is a matter of ‘following butterflies’ but
challenges each young woman in complex ways and with complex characters and
relationships as they navigate through the terrain of imagination.
Enchanted
worlds are a rich terrain for game space. In the history of computer games, we
see inklings of this in the original Myst (Cyan Worlds, 2003). The
long-standing best-selling CD-ROM and its antecedents greatly expanded the
female audience of digital entertainment. Rich in content and story, Myst transported players to imaginary worlds, and exploited the ‘portal’ concept
described above, using books as the magic entrée into parallel universes. While
the early Myst games revolve primarily around male characters, Myst
Online: Uru (2007) (their multiplayer online sequel) features
Yeesha, a female protagonist engaged in a conflict around the enslavement of a
secret race held captive in the dungeons of an underground city. Yeesha is a
kind of freedom fighter within the imaginary world. The gameplay, as with all Myst games, revolves around complex puzzles, unraveling narrative riddles and
labyrinthine plot twists, with a core game mechanic of discovery. Uru is
unique among MMOGs in that it is a purely cooperative game with no points, no
levels, no combat and no competition. The combination has appeal across genders
and ages, but has a particularly strong draw to older gamers and women. The Myst games take this notion of enchanted worlds to a high art form, and, like some of
their literary predecessors, explore the allegorical and sublime aspects of the
genre, rather than focusing on conquest or territorial conflict within them.
Other game worlds that follow this trajectory include the Zelda series (Nintendo,
1986), Ico (Sony, 2001), and Shadow of the Colossus (Sony, 2005),
each of which present worlds filled with wonder and magic, as well as terror
and danger. Notably, each also enmeshes the exploration of space with the
rescue of a princess.
Domestic Spaces
Lived
domestic space itself is also another important site of play and exploration
often portrayed in children’s literature. Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women (Alcott, 1900) is arguably the definitive work in this genre, depicting and
embodying a transitional space between girlhood and womanhood. Here the ‘little
women’ are in-transit from one mode to another. The ‘attic’, like Mary’s
garden, serves as a kind of girls-only clubhouse in which the sisters can
engage in all manner of make-believe and collective daydreaming. This unique
scenario is made possible by the absence of men, whose disappearance from the
domestic scene during the Civil War creates a uniquely female-centric
environment in the home. Only the boy Laurie and the old man, his grandfather,
speak to any male presence in this female-centric story. Even when the men
return in the second half of the book, they play a secondary role, though their
presence certainly represents a tectonic shift in the household. Heroine Jo
evokes Woolf’s image of Jane Austen, sitting in the family parlor room quietly
writing her grand novels amidst the hustle and bustle of a busy household (Woolf,
1929).
Woolf
considers Austen’s a uniquely female voice. Indeed, Pride and Prejudice (Austen, 1813) centers on the doings of the women in the Bennet family,
although their actions revolve almost entirely around the males, who, while
dominating the power structures, seem to recede into the background in terms of
personality and charisma. Even Darcy, the romantic focal point of the lead
character, is a quiet, brooding and frankly not very interesting individual.
The women in the story may come off at times as petty and materialistic, but
they are certainly more dynamic than the majority of the men. The core
mechanic, of the narrative, if one can call it that, is the elaborate
machinations around relationships of gender and power.
Unlike
literature, where domestic space has been front and center, especially in the
form of the novel, it has been largely absent from gaming. Janet Murray points
out the Holodeck milestone of Star Trek: The Next Generation’s Captain
Janeway’s Lucy Davenport, an open ended narrative of domestic life that
looks more like a 19th Century novel than the violent conflicts
preferred by the male crew members (Murray, 1997). Domestic space has been
explored by a number of women game researchers, including Mary Flanagan and
Maia Engeli, both of whom have used the context of ‘art’ to address this
oversight (Flanagan, 2003; Engeli, 2000; Engeli, 2005). As Bachelard points
out, domestic space has always been and continues to be a strongly female
domain; while men inhabit domestic space, it is women who create it: ‘In the
intimate harmony of walls and furniture, it may be said that we become
conscious of a house that is built by women, since men only know how to build a
house from the outside, and they know little or nothing of the “wax” of
civilization’ (Bachelard, 1964).
The Sims, more than any other game, answers
Bachelard’s question: ‘…how can housework be made into a creative activity?’
The Sims was both radical and baffling to some for its preoccupation with
the mundane, domestic life of ordinary characters. It in a sense inverted the
classic game formula, stepping away from the action of the battlefield or the
adventures of the fantastical. Designer Will Wright, no doubt one of the more
androgynous minds in the game industry, is very conscious of the metaphors
operating in his games. He describes his original ‘sim’ game, Sim City (Maxis,
1989), as having the obvious metaphor of ‘a model railroad come to life’,
but the mechanic is more that of a garden (Pearce, 2002). As Bachelard (1964) so
eloquently states:
The cleverer I am at miniaturizing the world, the better I
possess it.
Miniature is an exercise that has metaphysical freshness; it
allows us to be world conscious at slight risk. And how restful this exercise
on a dominated world can be!
According to
designer Will Wright, while The Sims can be equated with a dollhouse — a
miniature household complete with miniature problems and relationships — the game
mechanic is in actuality more complex, depending on individual play styles.
Often, he says, players start in one mode and veer off in a different
direction. For some, the game mechanic feels more like juggling, trying to
balance a variety of tasks. For others, it’s more of a construction activity,
with a focus on building or modifying the home. Still others have adopted the
game as a kind of virtual sound stage in which to create stories (Pearce, 2002).
This echoes what co-author Morie called ‘re-active worlds’, which she predicted
would prevail in the future of VR (Morie, 1992).
Narrative
Spaces
Myst,
Zelda, and Shadow
of the Colossus all take place in spaces that convey a story. Early
research into games and gender (Pearce, 1997; Laurel, 2001), found that women
and girls resonate with games that have storylines and character development,
and they might even stray from the game’s goals to explore a secondary
plotline. These are what Pearce has called ‘narrative environments’ and
Flanagan terms ‘navigable narratives’. Similar to the labyrinth described by
Murray (1997), they utilize techniques of spatial storytelling to convey
aspects of the narrative. Players discover, uncover and reveal the plot
elements as they progress through the game. Thus rather than a terrain of
contested territory, the game becomes a space imbued with story and mystery to
be discovered and uncovered.
Constructing and Cultivating Space
Doll
Houses and Gardens
The Sims also falls into the category of what
one might call constructing or cultivating space. This engages the garden
metaphor, as well as the notion of players creating or building the game as
they play it. Players also use The Sims to create their own stories, and
its skinning tools to create their own characters and objects. A more primitive
precedent to this was Little Computer People (Activision, 1985), a
Commodore 64 dollhouse simulation. We can see the convergence of the fantasy
environment with constructivist play is the asynchronous multiplayer console
game Animal Crossing (Nintendo EAD, 2002). In this game, players live,
work, play and are part of a community that grows and changes from day to day,
season to season. Once the initial training has taken place, players are free
to do as they wish: catching insects, fishing, picking fruit, gathering nuts,
collecting sea shells, digging for fossils or composing a new town song.
Players can sell items they catch or find for ‘bells’ (the Animal Crossing currency) or, if the player has a degree of community spirit, they may choose
to donate items to the Museum for the enjoyment of all. The Museum will accept
one of each unique item — one of each type of fish, each type of insect, each
painting, etc. While some types of fish, for example, are prevalent in the
game’s waters, others can only be caught at a certain time of day (or night) or
at a certain season of the year. Players dedicated to creating a Museum
showcasing all the varieties of fish or insects in the Animal Crossing world
must work at it diligently, for no other reason than community pride, as items
donated to the Museum bring no material gain to the player. This altruistic
feature is particularly interesting, as it taps into a theme often seen in the
children’s literature referenced above. Like Little Women’s Amy
painting miniatures to sell at a charity event, Mary’s dedication to
cultivating her ‘little bit of earth’ and sharing it with Colin in The
Secret Garden, or Oz’s Dorothy’s nurturing her ragtag crew, the pride
of accomplishment and being part of a community that is grateful for the fruit
of one’s labor are key pleasures embedded in the game space and its play
mechanics.
The garden
concept can also be seen in the console game Okami (Clover Studio Co,
2006). Here players take the role of a wolf Goddess to bring back to life the
bleak landscape of a cursed land. Throughout the game, the Goddess bonds with
the denizens of the world, sows seeds of good will by giving them food and
gifts, leaves a trail of flowers in her path, and brings dead things to life
with a Japanese sumi-e brush, with which she can also vanquish evil
spirits in battle. With its spiritual themes, deep connection to the natural
world, and constructivist gameplay, Okami provides another model for
alternative, regendered game space. We see these themes re-emerge throughout
both Japanese game space, as in the Zelda series, and anime, such as the films
of Miyazaki.
Constructing
Community Space
This form of
additive or constructivist gameplay represents an emerging and growing
direction in video games, and one that seems to resonate with female players,
both children and adults. In games like Animal Crossing and The Sims,
players actually contribute to building the world. We also see a
predominance of female players, particularly the supposedly elusive adult
woman, in multiplayer virtual worlds such as There.com (There, Inc.,
2003) and Second Life (Linden Lab, 2003), where the pleasure of play is
categorically linked to creative mastery. In The Sims, the number one
character ‘skin’ is Britney Spears, created by numerous tween fans of the
performer. Environments like There.com and Second Life provide
adults with numerous opportunities for creativity, merging fantasy with
constructivist play. It is also clear that the game designers have explicitly
targeted female players. In both virtual worlds, fashion is a prevalent form of
player productivity, dominated by female players as both consumers and
creators. Architecture and design contribute to the construction of the world
itself, with women being among the most recognized designers in both virtual
worlds. These sorts of creative engagements are particularly appealing when
they take place in a social context; while women may be less motivated to work
with 3D graphics software for its own sake, doing so in a context of social
agency seems to provide the extra motivation needed to develop a wide range of
technical and creative skills that might otherwise go untapped (Pearce, 2006).
Social
Spaces: Women and MMOGs
One genre
where we see growing participation from women, although they still represent
less than 20% of the typical gaming population, is massively multiplayer online
games (MMOGs) (Yee, 2003; Seay et al, 2004). T.L. Taylor, one of the few scholars
writing about women’s play preferences in this area, points out that a key
pleasure for women is exploration. She cites a study by Schott and Horrell,
who found that ‘Although…girl gamers…avoided competitive play, they did find a
similar engagement with exploration suggesting that “respondents were focused
around the freedom that RPGs (role-playing games) gave to exploration of its
virtual environment for the accumulation of symbols that possess general life
enhancing qualities”’ (Schott, 2000). It should be noted that while exploration
is a prevalent feature of MMOGs, it usually produces a fraction of the ‘experience
points’ of combat activities, suggesting that what is a high-value play pattern
for women is of less value to game designers. Socializing, also of high value
among women, is seldom scored and sometimes inadvertently penalized. Further,
Taylor points out that in virtual worlds women have a unique status in that
they are in no more physical danger than their male counterparts, which would not
be the case for a similar situation in real life (Taylor, 2003).
Bearing in
mind that role-playing MMOGs have many appealing factors for women, one has to
wonder why they are not more popular with female players? In spite of
their inclusiveness, there are other implicit and explicit demarcations that
bar women from the playground, and can sometimes take the form of blatant
player discrimination. Avatar representation is one: women often grudgingly
accept the representations they are offered (Taylor, 2003; Pearce, 2006).
Another is mechanics, which disproportionately reward combat activities;
another may be the linear achievement model of success. There may also be
social factors involved. Players in female avatars (whether male or female)
frequently report sexual harassment. In a study by Pearce of Baby Boomer
Gamers, one female Battlefield 1942 (Digital Illusions, 2002) player
recalled being told ‘this game is not for girls,” spurring her to join an ‘Older
Gamers’ guild, where she found she was treated with respect (Pearce, 2006a).
Pearce’s
research with players of the Myst-based MMOG Uru revealed a
number of relevant findings. Fifty percent of the study subjects were female
(an extremely rare ratio for any game study), and players ranged in age from
the teens to the seventies. Pearce did not find any major distinction between
male and female play styles, but it was clear that cooperative exploration and
puzzle solving were the characteristic preferences of this community. They
were less interested in competition and most were by and large disinterested in
games that entailed killing or combat. One interesting quality of this group
was the ways in which they “read” the space; because they were tuned to the Myst style of navigation and puzzle solving, they were always looking for secrets,
clues and story threads. The architectural structures created by these players
in There.com, for instance, usually included hidden rooms that required
some problem solving to access (Pearce, 2006). These players saw games and
virtual worlds not as realms to be conquered, nor as tactical battlefields.
Rather, they saw them as scenic, social environments where one could, as
Lisbeth Klastrup puts it, ‘joyfully dwell in the virtual world’.
Virtual Reality as Regendered Play Space
Drawing
from Precedents in VR
One area
where we can explore more gender-balanced approaches to constructing spatial
gaming experiences is in the field of virtual reality (VR). While VR is
considered by some to be passé, supplanted to a certain extent by the
ubiquitous rise of screen-based gaming, the medium has a rich continuing
history of artistic experimentation. Due in part to the creative potential of
full sensory immersion, as well as the research and artistic frameworks in
which it is developed, it is not surprising that a significant number of early
influential virtual reality projects were created by women. Unfettered by
commercial conventions, women have been able to freely explore and construct a
wide range of digital spaces that, while seldom ‘games’, both exemplify and
inspire the imaginative potential of game space. As Marie-Laure Ryan has
pointed out, ‘The virtual is an inexhaustible resource’ (Ryan, 2001).
What makes
these places — these inhabitable digital spheres in full three dimensions — different
than the game spaces discussed thus far? Hélène Cixous and other
poststructuralist feminists studied how gender was created and/or destabilized
within the structure of the medium, with particular focus on writing (Cixous,
1981). If we expand these ideas to the realm of Virtual Environments, we start
to see interesting patterns that begin to stabilize a feminist perspective of
creation. While hundreds of Virtual Environments have been built since VR’s
heyday in the early 1990s, most of those that emerged from male-dominated
laboratories were rationally built architectural spaces. In contrast, those
made by women (primarily women artists who have gained access to the equipment)
interpret the medium from completely different viewpoints, and provide some
insights into potential future directions for regendering game space. In this
section, we describe selected works that exemplify these differences.
Narrative/Performative Space
Co-author
Pearce developed a VR theme park experience that placed players in teams for an
underwater adventure to save the Loch Ness Monster’s eggs (Pearce, 1994). This
attraction was specifically designed to appeal to diverse ages and particularly
to women, based on the theme parks industry’s model of targeting diverse
audiences and marketing to female heads of households. Combining a scenic
underwater fantasy environment, team-based cooperative and competitive play, a
treasure hunt/exploratory game mechanic, and prehistoric monsters, resulted in
a game that appealed across a broad spectrum of player types.
Figure 1. Virtual
Adventures, designed by Celia Pearce for Iwerks Entertainment and Evans
& Sutherland in 1993.
Another key
example is Brenda Laurel and Rachel Strickland’s PLACEHOLDER (Laurel et
al, 1994), which sought to use digital space as a means to inscribe landscape
with a sense of spirituality and narrative. Drawing from local landscapes and
native lore around the around the Banff Centre in Alberta, Canada (where the
piece was developed), they placed players in the roles of animals who could
explore landscapes, listen to and leave their own stories behind. A highly
evocative piece focusing on embodiment and relationship to nature, PLACEHOLDER aimed to create a radically different experience of virtual reality than we see
in some of the games described earlier. Laurel was also building ideas
presented in her influential book, Computers as Theater (Laurel, 1991),
in which she introduces the idea of computers creating a ritual and
performative space not unlike the traditional role of theater.
Emotional Space
Co-author
Morie has worked primarily with the emotional space afforded by virtual
environments (Morie et al, 2005). Her VR work Virtopia created with Mike
Goslin in the early 1990s was a series of diverse experiences to which a
participant traveled by plunging into brightly colored pools at oases sprinkled
about a vast virtual desert (Morie and Goslin, 1992-1994). Each world provided
a space that evoked a particular emotion: for example, angst in the case of ‘Fang
City’ and nostalgia in ‘The Conversation Room’. Her most recent work, The
Memory Stairs (Morie, 2004-present) explores the psychic space of memories
and the deeply hidden emotions associated with them.
Figure 2.
Laurel and Strickland’s Placeholder allowed players to add voice
annotations to a virtual world.
(Images
used with permission from the artists.)
Figure 3.
Jacquelyn Ford Morie’s Memory Stairs
(Images
used with permission from the artist.)
Rita
Addison’s Detour: Brain Deconstruction Ahead (1995a) is an example of ‘empathic
VR’. In this installation, created with Marcus Thieubaux, David Zeltzer, and
Dave Swoboda at the Electronic Visualization Lab at the University of Illinois
Chicago, photographer Addison documented the sensory damage she sustained as a
result of a brain injury. The piece was designed to convey an emotional
experience that Addison found impossible to describe with words (1995). She
subsequently created similar works to help family members of stroke victims
better understand what their loved ones were experiencing.
Figure 4.
Rita Addison’s CAVE-based Detour: Brain Deconstruction Ahead was hailed
as the first ‘empathic’ VR.
(Images
used with permission from the artist.)
Char Davies’ Osmose (1995) is a unique exploration of personal psychic and emotional space. Davies
sought to shift the focus from action and agency to presence and immersion, or
what she terms “immersence.” “Immersents” were placed into a sublime
relationship with an abstract environment that blended naturalistic forms with
highly technological representation and textual poetry. There was no overt goal
and using a head-mounted display and sensors, players navigated in a fashion
modeled after SCUBA diving, inhaling to rise, exhaling to sink and leaning from
side to side to navigate. This is a radically different relationship to space
than games such as Doom, which are focused on tactical agency and
strategic exploitation of spatial constraints. Visitors to this environment
described falling into a meditative state (McRobert, 2006).
Figure 5.
Char Davies’s Osmose used a SCUBA diving metaphor as the interface to
navigate a sublime spiritual space. (Images used with permission.)
Procedural Space
The work of
Artificial Life (A-Life) artists Christa Sommerer and Laurent Mignonneau
prefigured some of what we have begun to see with recent more “procedurally”
oriented approaches to space. The Nintendo DS Game Electroplankton (Nintendo,
2006), for instance, has some resemblance to their A-Volve (Sommerer,
1994), a VR installation in which players created their own creatures and
encouraged them interact in a pool of actual water. Sommerer and Mignonneau
have also created an installation where various plants sprout where you stand,
and another in which moths are made to follow a player-controlled flashlight.
These spaces follow the ‘garden’ model described earlier, where the player is
engaged in the cultivation of natural spaces and creatures. Other examples
include Rebecca Allen’s Bush Soul Nos. 1-3 (Allen, 1997-1999), in which
players enter into dynamic relationships with virtual creatures, and Jane
Prophet and Gordon Selley’s TechnoSphere (Prophet and Selley, 1995). We
anticipate that we will see the emergence of this type of space with the
upcoming game Spore (Maxis, 2000), in which players create and nurture
their own evolving organisms in a 3D world.
Conclusion
The
construction of space in the mainstream videogame industry has evolved
primarily around male models of space and agency. In this paper, we identify a
direction for a new poetics of game space that is more inclusionary and gender
balanced, and advocate, after Woolf, for an androgynous mind of game design.
Drawing from classic literature, as well as contemporary practices of VR art,
we have provided illustrations of the rich diversity of inclusionary game space
possibilities. Although they represent only a handful of examples, these
experiments in alternative space all possess a quality decidedly lacking in many
video games: a sense of wonder, a sense of the sublime, a sense of awe. Players
seek to experience a sense of wonder within a magical world, a key pleasure of
the literary forms described above. We encourage the exploration of these and
other unique spaces in game design and game culture, towards more egalitarian
and expanded domains for play where everyone can feel included, inspired,
enlivened and entertained.
Authors' Biographies
Jacquelyn Ford Morie is a Senior Researcher at the university of
Southern California's Institute for Creative Technologies (http://www.ict.usc.edu). Her research includes fully
immersive multi‑sensory virtual environments as well as new mobile
technologies used in the service of training and education. She is a
member and co‑founder of the game collective Ludica and is a visiting
lecturer in game design at the Unversity of California, Los Angeles.
Morie holds masters degrees in both Fine Arts and Computer Science, and
was awarded her PhD in 2007 for her Immersive Environment research from
the SMARTLab at the University of East London.
Links:
http://www.ict.usc.edu/~Emorie ,
http://www.ict.usc.edu/,http://www.ludica.org.uk/
Tracy Fullerton, M.F.A., is an Assistant Professor in the Interactive
Media Division of the USC School of Cinematic Arts and co‑Director of
the Electronic Arts Game Innovation Lab where she does design research
in new genres of gameplay. Prior to joining the USC faculty, she was a
professional game designer for fifteen years; her textbook on the design
process Game Design Workshop: A Playcentric Approach to Creating
Innovative Games is in use at game programs worldwide. Tracy's recent
credits include faculty advisor for the award‑winning student games
Cloud and flOw and game designer for The Night Journey, a unique
game/art project with media artist Bill Viola.
Links:
http://www.tracyfullerton.com/, http://interactive.usc.edu, http://www.ludica.org.uk/
Celia Pearce, Ph.D., is an Assistant Professor of Digital Media in the
School of Literature, Communication and Culture at Georgia Tech, where
she also directs the Experimental Game Lab and the Emergent Game Group.
Previously she helped launch gaming and media arts initiatives at
University of California Irvine and University of Southern California.
Prior to entering academia, she was a designer interactive attractions,
exhibitions and games. Her game designs include the award‑winning
attraction Virtual Adventures (for Iwerks and Evans & Sutherland) and
the Purple Moon Friendship Adventure Cards for Girls. She is has
authored numerous papers and book chapters, as well as The Interactive
Book (Macmillan 1997) and Communities of Play: Emergent Cultures in
Online Games and Virtual Worlds (scheduled for publication by MIT in
2009.) She is also Festival Chair for IndieCade and co‑founder of
Ludica, a women's game collective. Links: http://www.cpandfriends.com, http://egl.gatech.edu, http://egg.lcc.gatech.edu, http://www.ludica.org.uk
Notes
[1] A number
of studies, including the IGDA report on industry demographics in the U.S. (http://www.igda.org/diversity/report.php)
and Li Haines’ 2004 report Why are there so few women in games? for
Manchester: Media Training Northwest. [back]
[2] The schism
between ‘real’ games and games played primarily by women can be seen in the
fact that the premier online game database Moby Games only accepts entries for
games published on disk or available as full downloadable packages. No
web-only games, such as those created in Flash or Shockwave, are included in
their knowledge-base. Moby also has no reference to any of the titles from
Purple Moon. [back]
[3] That said,
there are certain contexts in which women and girls can and do derive pleasure
from competing on equal terms in male space. The Frag Dolls, for instance, a
professional women’s gaming team initiated by developer Ubisoft, are champions
at games such as Splinter Cell (2002). And Grrlgamer.com is a web site devoted to female players where female-targeted reviews weigh
equally between more ‘hardcore’ (read: male-centered) games and those that
might traditionally be thought of us more female-friendly, such as casual game Diner
Dash or Pet Pals: Animal Doctor. [back]
[4] American
McGee’s Alice (Rogue Entertainment, 2000) is a re-imagining of the classic
story using the mechanics of a first-person shooter game. In this cynical
version of the adventure, Alice is traumatized and institutionalized before
returning to a much-changed Wonderland where she battles through gnome-ridden
tunnels and boojum-guarded strongholds armed with a rusty ‘vorpal blade’ (from
the original Jabberwocky) and razor-sharp playing cards. In this more
male-oriented game design, the imaginative word play and puzzling incongruity
of the original ‘game world’ of Wonderland is replaced with direct conflict and
dangerous environments. [back]
References
Aarseth, E. ‘Allegories of Space: The Question of Spatiality
in Computer Games’ in M. Eskelinen and R. Koskimaa (eds) Cybertext Yearbook 2000 (University of Jyväskylä , 2001).
Addison, R.
‘Detour: Brain Deconstruction Ahead’, IEEE Computer Graphics and
Applications vol.12, no. 2 (March 1995): 14-17.
Addison, R. Detour: Brain Deconstruction Ahead. CAVE-based Virtual Reality
Installation with D. Zeltzer, M. Thiebaux. and D. Swoboda, D (1995).
Alcott, L.M. Little Women (New York: Books, Inc., 1900
[1868]).
Allen, R. Bush
Soul, Nos. 1-3. Virtual Reality Installations (1997-1999).
Austen, J. Pride and Prejudice (Oxford, UK: Oxford
University Press, 1813).
Bachelard, G. The Poetics of Space (New York: Orion
Press, 1964 [1958]).
Baum, L. F. The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (Chicago: George
M. Hill, 1900).
Bungie
Studios. Halo 2 (Microsoft Game Studios, 2004).
Bungie
Studios. Myth: The Fallen Lords (Eidos, Inc., 1997).
Burnett, F.
H. The Secret Garden (London: William Heinemann, 1909).
Butler, J. Gender
Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (New York, Routledge: 1990).
Carroll, L. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland (London,
UK: Macmillan, 1865).
Carroll, L. Through the Looking-Glass, and What Alice Found
There (London: Macmillan, 1871).
Cixous, H. ‘The Laugh of the Medusa’, trans. Keith and Paula
Cohen. in E. Marks and I. de Courtivron, I (eds), New French Feminisms: An
Anthology (New York: Schocken Books, 1981): 245-47.
Clover
Studio Co., Ltd. Okami (Capcom Entertainment, Inc., 2006).
Core Design
Ltd. Tomb Raider (Eidos Interactive, 1996).
Cyan
Worlds. Myst (Brøderbund, 1993).
Cyan
Worlds. Uru: Ages Beyond Myst (Original Beta published by Ubi Soft in
2003; re-published by Turner/Gametap as Myst Online: Uru Live, 2007).
Davies, C. Osmose, Virtual Reality Installation (1995).
De Beauvoir, S. The Second Sex (New York: Random
House, 1952).
Digital Illusions. Battlefield 1942 ( Electronic
Arts, 2002).
Downing, F. Remembrance and the Design of Place (College
Station TX: Texas A&M University Press, 2000).
Duchenaut, N., R. J. Moore and E. Nickell. Designing for
Sociability in Massively Multiplayer Games: an Examination of the ‘Third
Places’ of SWG, in Conference Proceedings for Other Players, Center
for Computer Games Research, IT University of Copenhagen, DK (2004),
http://www.itu.dk/op/proceedings.htm
Engeli, M. Doll House (Game workshop, Technical
University Graz, Austria, 2005).
Engeli, M. Through the Looking Glass. Unreal Tournament
game mod (2000).
Ensemble
Studios. Age of Empires (Microsoft Game Studios, 1997).
Flanagan,
M. ‘navigable narratives: gender + narrative spatiality in virtual worlds’, Art
Journal. Vol. 59 no. 3 (Fall 2000): 74 - 85.
Flanagan,
M. [domestic]. Unreal Tournament game mod, 2003.
Flanagan,
M. Playculture: developing a feminist game design. Ph.D. Thesis,
SMARTlab Centre, Central Saint Martins College of Art and Design, London, UK (2005).
GameLab. Diner
Dash (PlayFirst, 2003).
Gilman, C.
P. Herland (New York: Pantheon, 1979 [1915]).
Gilman, C. P. The Man-Made World: or; Our Androcentric
Culture (New York: Carlton, 1911).
Gilman, C. P. The Yellow Wallpaper in
C.P. Gilman,The Yellow Wall-paper” and Other Stories (New York; Dover, 1997
[1892]).
Grrlgamer web site. http://www.grrlgamer.com/
id
Software. Doom (Activision, 1993).
Jenkins, H. ‘Complete Freedom of Movement: Video Games as
Gendered Play Spaces’ in J. Cassell and H. Jenkins (eds) From Barbie to
Mortal Kombat: Gender and computer games (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1998).
Konzack, L. Sub-creation of Secondary Game Worlds in Games
2006 : iDiG - International Digital Games Conference Proceedings (Portalegre,
Portugal, 2006): 115-122.
Laurel, B. Utopian Entrepreneur (Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press, 2001).
Laurel, B., Computers As Theater (Reading, MA: Addison
Wesley, 1991).
Laurel, B., R. Strickland and R Tow ‘PLACEHOLDER: Landscape
and Narrative in Virtual Environments’, in ACM Computer Graphics Quarterly, vol.
28, no. 2 (May 1994): 118 – 126.
Le, Min and
Jess Cliffe (aka ‘Team Counter-Strike’) Counter-Strike Half-Life mod (self-published,
1999).
Lefebvre, H. The Production of Space (Oxford, UK: Blackwell,
1991).
Legacy Games. Pet Pals: Animal Doctor (2006).
Lewis, C. S. The Chronicles of Narnia (Oxford, UK: Oxford
University Press, 1950).
Linden Lab. Second Life (Linden Lab, 2003).
Margolis,
L. and A. Fisher. Unlocking the Clubhouse: Women in Computing (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2001).
Maxis. Sim City (Maxis/Brøderbund, 1989).
Maxis. Spore (Electronic Arts, 2000, in development).
Maxis. The
Sims (Electronic Arts, 2000).
McRobert, L. Char Davies' Immersive Virtual Art and the
Essence of Spatiality (Toronto, CN: University of Toronto Press, 2006).
Micropose Software, Civilization (Micropose Software,
1992).
Morie, J. F. The Future of Ambiguity in Art: Art of the
Fourth Dimension, presented at The Third International Symposium on
Electronic Art, Sydney, Australia (1992).
Morie, J.F.
and Goslin, J. Virtopia. Virtual Reality Installation (1992-1994).
Morie, J.F. Memory Stairs. Virtual Reality Installation ( 2004-present).
Morie, J.F., J. Williams, A. Dozois and D-P Luigi. ‘The
Fidelity of Feel: Emotional Affordance in Virtual Environments’, in Proceedings
of the 11th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction, Las
Vegas, NV (2005).
Murray, J. Hamlet on the Holodeck: The Future of
Narrative in Cyberspace (New York: The Free Press, 1997).
Muse
Software. Castle Wolfenstein (Muse Software, 1981).
Namco, Ltd. Tekken (Namco Hometek, 1995).
Newson, J.
and Newson, E. Four Years Old in an Urban Community (Chicago IL: Aldine,
1968).
Nintendo
Co., Ltd. Electroplankton, Nintendo DS Game (Nintendo of America, 2006).
Nintendo
Co., Ltd. Super Mario Brothers (Nintendo of America, 1985).
Nintendo
Co., Ltd. The Legend of Zelda (Nintendo Co., Ltd., 1986).
Nintendo
EAD. Animal Crossing (Nintendo of America, 2002).
Norman, M. and L. Simon. The Secret Garden (musical play
based on the book by Frances Hodgson Burnett), lyrics by Marsha Norman, St.
James Theatre, London, UK (25 April 1991- January, 1993).
Oldenburg,
R. The Great Good Place: Cafés, Coffee Shops, Community Centers, Beauty
Parlors, General Stores, Bars, Hangouts, and How They Get You Through The Day (New York: Paragon House, 1989).
Pearce, C. Playing
Ethnography: A Study of Emergent Behaviour in Online Games and Virtual World, Ph.D. Thesis, Central Saint Martins College of Art and Design, University of
the Arts, London ( 2006).
Pearce, C.
(2006a). The Truth About Baby Boomer Gamers. Commissioned report,
pending publication.
Pearce, C.
(Creative Director) Virtual Adventures: The Loch Ness Expedition. Virtual Reality Attraction, produced by Iwerks Entertainment and Evans &
Sutherland, Newquist, E. (Executive Producer), 1994.
Pearce, C. The
Interactive Book: A Guide to the Interactive Revolution (Indianapolis, IN:
Macmillan, 1997).
Pearce, C. ‘Sims,
BattleBots, Cellular Automata, God and Go: A Conversation with Will Wright’, Game
Studies Journal,vol. 2, issue 1 (July 2002)
http://www.gamestudies.org/0102/pearce/
Prophet, J.
and Selley, G. TechnoSphere, Virtual Reality Networked Art Piece (1995).
Purple Moon
Software. Secret Paths Series (1996-1998).
Robinett,
W. Adventure (Atari, 1980).
Rockstar
North Ltd. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (Rockstar Games, Inc.).
Rogue
Entertainment. American McGee’s Alice (Electronic Arts, 2000).
Ryan, M.-L. Narrative as Virtual Reality: Immersion and Interactivity in Literature and
Electronic Media (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2001).
Sand, G. Consuelo (Paris: Charpentier, 1845).
Schott, G. R. and K. R. Horrell. ‘Girl Gamers and
Their Relationship with the Gaming Culture’, Convergence 6, 4 (2000):
36-53.
Seay, A., J.
Fleming, J. William, K. Sang Lee and R.E. Kraut. ‘Project massive: a study of
online gaming communities’ in Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems,
CHI '04, Vienna, Austria (2004): 1421–1424.
SEGA-AM2
Co., LTD. Virtua Fighter. SEGA Corporation, 1995.
Smith, N.
A. Boys and Girls of Bookland (New York: Cosmopolitan Book Corporation,
1923).
Soja, E. Thirdspace:
Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real and Imagined Places (Oxford UK: Blackwell
Publishers, 1996).
Sommerer,
C. and L. Mignonneau. A-Volve Virtual Reality Installation (1994).
Sony
Computer Entertainment of America, Inc. Ico (Sony Computer Entertainment
of America, Inc., 2001).
Sony Computer
Entertainment of America, Inc. Shadow of the Colossus (Sony Computer
Entertainment of America, Inc., 2005).
Taylor, T.L. ‘Multiple Pleasures: Women and Online Gaming’, Convergence
9, 1 (2003), 21-46.
Terlecki,
M. S. and N.S. Newcombe. ‘How Important Is the Digital Divide? The Relation of
Computer and Videogame Usage to Gender Differences in Mental Rotation Ability’,
in Sex Roles vol. 53, no. 5-6 (September 2005): 433-441.
There, Inc. There.com (Makena Technologies, 2003).
Travers,
P. L. Mary Poppins (New York: Harcourt, Brace & Co., 1934).
Ubi Soft
Montreal. Tom Clancy’s Splinter Cel (Ubi Soft Entertainment Software,
2002).
Valve
Software. Half-Life (Sierra On-Line, 1998).
Verant. EverQuest. (989 Studios, later published by Sony Online Entertainment, 1999).
Woolf, V. A
Room of One’s Own (New York: Harcourt Brace & Company, 1929.
Yee,
Nicholas. The Norrathian Scrolls, 2003. http://www.nickyee.com/daedalus/archives/000551.php?page=2
[TOP] |
